You Can’t be a Great Coach Without this Skill

There is one thing you need to understand to be a great coach: Emotions drive behavior. Sounds obvious, but many leaders and coaches I work with don’t understand this. Most people try to coach, lead, influence (and parent) behaviors.  As a new leader and coach early in my career, I too was focused on coaching behaviors.

You Can’t be a Great Coach Without this Skill

You can’t be a great coach that develops and inspires people if you only focus on their behaviors; you need to learn the Emotional Intelligence-based skill of connecting to the emotional needs that drive their behaviors.

Identifying Behaviors

As a coach, it’s important to identify specific behaviors that may be impacting someone’s performance and then help them course-correct.  But that’s just the start.

Early in my career when I was working at a software company, I was managing a highly technical and brilliant individual – let’s call him Joel.  The main issue that was derailing Joel’s effectiveness was that he was giving long and technical explanations and sending super-long e-mails full of technical jargon.  In meetings, I could see people’s eyes glaze over when he started going into a long explanation.   Being his manager (and therefore his coach), I’d interrupt Joel to “help” him keep from going on too long.  You can imagine how well that worked for him (not to mention how it looked to everyone else in those meetings).

When I had my first discussion (what I thought was a coaching session) where I shared the feedback with Joel, I gave him specific examples of times he had talked too long and shown him examples of his long e-mails.  He was a little defensive at first, but I used my “strong coach” tone to let him know the behavior needed to change.

Not surprisingly, his behavior didn’t change.  In fact, when I was in meetings with him, it seemed to get worse. (I realized later that he was nervous I’d interrupt him, which made him talk faster and longer). While I had done a decent job of pointing out Joel’s derailing behavior and redirected him to a new behavior,  I was missing a critical skill a leader/coach needs to have.

The Emotional Need Behind the Behavior

The most important skill you can develop as a coach is helping a person figure out their “why”.  Why are they behaving the way they are?  And specifically, what emotional needs are causing them to behave (or not behave) in a way that is detrimental to their growth and performance.

Let’s go back to Joel.  I had recently been through an Emotional Intelligence training session that focused on the how to connect to emotional needs that drive behaviors.   I made sure we had a good amount of time for a coaching session, that I was able to be present and be truly curious, and I had a whole list of  EI-based questions prepared.

It turned out that as a technical person, Joel valued when people explain things with the correct (his word) amount of detail.   In fact, he is impressed by people who can do this (his personality profile is analytical).  We were able to determine that he was giving the long explanations because he felt that would impress people and they would see him as credible, which would earn their respect.  His emotional need, to feel respected, is one that most of us have.   His strategy to earn respect was to explain things in great technical detail.

I explained to him that while his technical expertise is extremely important to the organization, that many people do not value long technical descriptions, and in fact, it can even annoy and frustrate them (think of people whose personality profiles are drivers).   I explained that the behavior of giving long, technical explanations could cause some people to disrespect him – i.e. for those people, it was having the exact opposite effect of meeting his emotional need!   He began to see that if he could be more aware of his audience and articulate his ideas in a more concise and simple manner when the situation merited that, he could earn a lot more respect.

This was a lightbulb moment for Joel.   He hadn’t realized why he was giving the long explanations, although he did know something wasn’t working right.  Realizing that behavior was in fact causing him to be less respected, motivated him to change his behavior.  With this understanding of his emotional need, his whole approach changed.  He started asking me if he was being concise enough in meetings. He’d send me e-mails to review before he sent them, and he was much more open to my feedback and suggestions.  I could tell he was working hard to improve.

People’s behaviors are like the tip of the iceberg and their emotional needs are everything under the surface.   Just like it’s hard to move an iceberg from the tip, it’s very difficult to coach and develop people without connecting to their emotional needs.

Examples of emotional needs we all have that drive our behaviors are:
• To be respected
• To feel valued and appreciated
• To have a voice
• To have choice
• To feel in control
• To be successful/competent
• To feel secure in our job/role
• To be liked (loved at home)
• To be trusted (and to trust)
• To have certainty (i.e. lack of change)
• To be included

This is not a complete list, but it hits most of the big emotional needs we all have.   Next time you are coaching someone (or yourself!), and you are trying to get them to behave in a certain way, ask yourself, what emotional needs are getting in the way of them behaving the way you need them to?  When you develop the skill of connecting to people’s emotional needs, that’s when you become a leader and coach that can unlock people’s full potential!

To learn more about developing the EI-based coaching skill of connecting to the emotions that drive people’s behaviors, attend one of our Science of Emotional Intelligence training programs which are available both in a classroom and virtually online:

Bill Benjamin is a training and leadership expert at the Institute for Health and Human Potential and a contributor to The New York Times best-selling book, “Performing Under Pressure.” Benjamin is a sought-after Emotional Intelligence speaker and is a regular contributor to CEO Magazine,, and Training Magazine. He works with people in high-pressure environments, including Intel, Goldman Sachs, Surgeons, and U.S. Marines.