A warning can reach an organisation without ever reaching the person who can act on it. A supervisor reports a problem, one department waits for another, and the final decision-maker remains occupied with something else. When the consequences become visible, everyone can point to a message they sent or a meeting they attended. Nobody can point to a decision made in time.
This is the hidden cost of a decision the CEO may not even know is waiting. During my work in security operations, I encountered a reported concern that did not receive a timely decision. The experience exposed the gap between recording a warning and securing an accountable response. I have withheld identifying and sensitive operational details, but the account reflects events I witnessed.
When waiting feels safer than deciding
There is a necessary difference between deliberation and hesitation. A leader facing an irreversible investment, a safety concern or a major restructuring should ask difficult questions. Deliberation tests evidence and identifies consequences. Hesitation keeps requesting certainty after the cost of waiting has become material.
Fear can sit behind that distinction. A manager may fear that approving an imperfect course of action will expose their judgement to criticism. Delaying it feels less visible. Where failed decisions are punished but unanswered recommendations attract little attention, the organisation creates an incentive to postpone responsibility. The message is never written into policy, yet people learn it quickly.
Not every cautious manager is protecting a career. Some are genuinely trying to avoid harm. The executive challenge is to make careful action possible without treating every unfavourable outcome as proof of incompetence. Otherwise, the organisation becomes skilled at preparing options and reluctant to choose among them.
Four failures that look like one delay
An unanswered warning can arise from at least four distinct failures. Information may be deliberately withheld to protect a department’s reputation or influence. A manager may instead fear personal blame for raising a concern that later proves unfounded. In another case, nobody may know who has authority to accept, escalate or close the risk. Finally, the named executive may simply be unavailable while the issue continues to develop. These are not interchangeable failures, and a generic instruction to ‘communicate better’ will not resolve them.
The remedies should differ. Suspected deliberate withholding calls for an independently accessible escalation channel, an auditable trail and fair investigation, not automatic accusations. Fear of blame calls for leaders who judge how a concern was raised and reasoned about, rather than punishing every warning that proves unnecessary. Unclear authority requires an explicit decision owner and thresholds for referral. Executive unavailability requires a designated alternate with pre-agreed powers and a time limit for acknowledgement. The solution must fit the obstruction.
Research helps explain one part of this problem: why employees speak up or remain silent. In a 2007 study involving 3,149 employees and 223 managers in a restaurant chain, James Detert and Ethan Burris found managerial openness more consistently associated with employees speaking up than transformational leadership, with perceived psychological safety helping explain the relationship. The study concerns employee voice, not executive decision speed, but it helps explain how leadership behaviour can affect whether useful information rises at all. Elizabeth Morrison’s 2014 review likewise examines why employees raise concerns or remain silent, and the organisational costs of withholding potentially useful information.
A first-hand lesson from security operations
In a situation I encountered during my professional work, recurring faults affected a system used to coordinate essential operations. A supervisor raised the concern, but technical and operational perspectives differed on its significance and the action required. Continued reliance on temporary measures required an authorised judgement about acceptable risk. The warning had been reported; the path to a decision was far less clear.
The delay was not solely technical. Disagreements among managers and competition over positions and authority complicated the route through which the concern should have moved. Departmental tensions made it harder to agree who should own the problem, who could escalate it and whose judgement would prevail. Without an effective route to an available decision-maker, the operational concern remained unresolved longer than it should have. These are the organisational dynamics I observed, not an attribution of unverified motives to any individual.
The significance of this experience is not that every reported fault demands a shutdown, nor that every managerial disagreement is improper. It is that internal rivalries must not be allowed to obstruct a time-sensitive risk decision. A named, authorised person should decide whether to act, monitor or formally accept a limited risk, within a defined period. Escalation should remain possible when managers disagree, and the decision trail should record who was informed and who was empowered to act. Silence must not masquerade as risk acceptance.
When the executive is busy
A CEO cannot personally address every issue. Yet an overloaded executive becomes a single point of failure when consequential decisions require one person’s approval with no alternative route. When the barrier is availability, the answer is delegated authority, clear escalation thresholds and a named substitute—not a demand that the CEO be permanently online. When the problem is fear, an additional approval layer may actually make silence worse.
The danger is greatest when employees are unsure whether bypassing a delayed manager would be considered responsible escalation or disloyalty. A reporting route that exists on paper but carries a career penalty for using it is not a functioning route.
What boards and CEOs can change
Three executive disciplines can make the route to a decision more reliable. First, set risk-based triggers for escalation, an acknowledgement deadline and a named alternate recipient. Let critical concerns bypass departmental bottlenecks without turning every disagreement into an emergency. Second, distinguish reversible protective measures from commitments that genuinely demand extended scrutiny. A temporary safeguard should not wait behind a process designed for an acquisition or permanent closure.
Third, review where a warning stopped and diagnose its cause before prescribing a remedy. Was it deliberately withheld, held back out of fear, left without a clear decision owner or delayed by an unavailable executive? Record when it was first raised, when it was acknowledged, who had decision rights and what happened next. Judge the reasonableness of the response against information available at the time, rather than treating an adverse outcome as proof of negligence.
Technology can help make a warning visible, but a dashboard cannot repair a culture in which people are afraid to raise it. Nor can an algorithm accept the moral and institutional responsibility for the consequences of action. Senior leaders must remain answerable, including when they choose not to act.
The research on psychological safety adds a caution: an organisation can publish an open-door policy while employees still assess speaking up as personally risky. Amy Edmondson’s 1999 study of 51 work teams linked psychological safety with team learning behaviour. The findings concern team learning, not a direct measure of CEO decision speed. They nevertheless reinforce the importance of both formal reporting authority and a climate in which people can actually use it. An independent route without trust may be ignored; trust without a route may leave a warning stranded.
The decision the leader never saw
Good executive judgement requires more than courage at the final meeting. It requires a workplace where colleagues can disagree without obstructing one another, where competition for authority does not determine whether a warning travels upward, and where an unavailable decision-maker does not stop the organisation from responding. These safeguards do not eliminate mistakes. They make it harder for silence, positional rivalry and administrative delay to become mistakes that nobody acknowledges.
The costliest decision may be the one a CEO never knew was waiting. Executive responsibility therefore begins before the final choice: with the design of a system in which serious warnings can reach an available, authorised person and receive an accountable response.
Selected research references
- Detert, J. R., & Burris, E. R. (2007). Leadership Behavior and Employee Voice: Is the Door Really Open? Academy of Management Journal, 50(4), 869–884. https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2007.26279183
- Morrison, E. W. (2014). Employee Voice and Silence. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 1, 173–197. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-031413-091328
- Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383. https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999
Author
Abdulla Saeed Alhebsi
Profile:
linkedin.com/in/abdulla-alhebsi
Social:
NA
Website:
asalhebsi.com
Abdulla Saeed Alhebsi, MIoL, is an Emirati author and independent researcher specialising in leadership, security operations, risk management and organisational resilience. He is a Member of the Institute of Leadership (UK).
